Third Circuit Dismisses Chemical Company’s Attempt to Invalidate EPA Water Advisory
The Third Circuit dismissed Chemours’s legal challenge to the EPA’s health advisory for the PFAS chemical HFPO-DA. While Chemours argued that the health advisory violated the Administrative Procedure Act and the nondelegation doctrine, the Third Circuit did not reach those conclusions and instead dismissed the action for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction. For the health advisory to be subject to review under the Safe Drinking Water Act, as Chemours argued, the health advisory would have to qualify as a “final action.” And ultimately the Third Circuit reasoned that the health advisory, which is not enforceable and non-regulatory, was not a final action because it did not directly bring about legal consequences or impose requirements or prohibitions.
July 23, 2024 | Chemours Co. FC LLC v. United States EPA, No. 22-2287 (3rd Cir.).
